Era 1 · 1840–1885
Frontier on Sarasota Bay
In 1840 the Army of Florida set up a headquarters, Fort Armistead, in Sarasota during the Seminole wars, and pioneer William Whitaker settled at "Yellow Bluffs, Sarasota Bay" in the 1840s. Sarasota got its first post office in 1878, and the frontier community was shaken when vigilantes murdered its first postmaster, Charles Abbe, in 1884.
Key moments
Army sets up Fort Armistead headquarters in Sarasota
During the Seminole wars, General Armistead, commander of the Army of Florida, established a new headquarters in Sarasota. Illness weakened the troops and the fort was abandoned after seven months.
Source
- The Historic Preservation Chapter, Sarasota City Plan and Support Document (adopted December 1, 2008), City of Sarasota (accessed 2026-09-29)
Sarasota gets its first post office
Sarasota's first post office opened in the store of Charles Abbe, in the area now known as Harbor Acres.
Source
- The first post office opens today, Historical Society of Sarasota County (accessed 2026-09-29)
Vigilantes murder postmaster Charles Abbe
Believing Sarasota's first postmaster, Charles Abbe, was plotting to cheat settlers out of homestead claims, a vigilante group murdered him. The New York Times carried the story on its front page.
Source
- The Historic Preservation Chapter, Sarasota City Plan and Support Document (adopted December 1, 2008), City of Sarasota (accessed 2026-09-29)
1 more from this era
Scottish colonists arrive in a newly platted Sarasota
The Edinburgh-based Florida Mortgage and Investment Co. sold Scottish settlers land in Sarasota, advertised as a tropical paradise. The settlers found no streets, roads or stores; most left, but some stayed.
Source
- Preserve America Community: Sarasota, Florida, Advisory Council on Historic Preservation (accessed 2026-09-29)
Sources
- The Historic Preservation Chapter, Sarasota City Plan and Support Document (adopted December 1, 2008), City of Sarasota (accessed 2026-09-29)
- The Historic Preservation Chapter, Sarasota City Plan and Support Document (adopted December 1, 2008), City of Sarasota (accessed 2026-09-29)
- The first post office opens today, Historical Society of Sarasota County (accessed 2026-09-29)


